EU commission to pay millions in compensation to software firm


By Martin Banks
- 3rd March 2011
This is an absolute disgrace

Marta Andreasen

Parliament's budgets committee has approved the use of €12m of taxpayer's money to pay for damages to a language translation software company whose programme is used by the European commission's translation services.

The commission made changes to the system belonging to Systran SA in breach of copyright and, on 16 December, the European court ordered the executive to pay damages.

In a vote on Thursday, the budgets committe gave its approval for the damages to be paid out of the EU budget.

No-one from the commission was immediately available for comment but the move has sparked outcry among Eurosceptic members of the committee.

UKIP MEP Marta Andreasen, who sits on the budgets committee and who the only member to vote against giving the damages said, "The commission should hang its head in shame.

"They are burdening EU taxpayers with €12m because of gross ineptitude. What's more they are using shotgun tactics on the committee by threatening that the European court judgment is irrevocable and late payment would carry interest charges.

"Not content with trying to regulate every aspect of our lives, the commission and parliament now want the general public to pay for their multi-million cock-ups. This is an absolute disgrace."

A spokesman for UK Conservative MEPs said, "It is unfortunate that this decision has gone against the commission, however there is an appeal still pending so it is not the end of the matter.

"We would of course much rather this amount did not have to be paid, but it is a legal requirement, and failure to do so would be in breach of the law and the commission would be liable for further action.

"Should the appeal be successful, and we are hopeful, the money will be repaid."

Related News

Ireland made 'fundamental mistake' in joining single currency

EU condemned over 'ridiculous' wine ruling

Irish voters urged to back EU fiscal treaty

Public private partnerships key to growth of EU pharma research

Campaigners press for 'fundamental change' at EU food agency



Latest news

Concern over incoming Cypriot presidency dismissed as 'manufactured'

British S&D member Richard Howitt has branded concerns about the upcoming Cypriot presidency of the EU as "manufactured"


EU urged to do more to combat homophobic bullying

Senior MEP Edward McMillan-Scott says "much remains to be done" to improve the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender people


Ukraine premier says he 'welcomes' EU election observers

Ukrainian prime minister Mykola Azarov says he would welcome the presence of observers from the EU during the country's national elections later this year


Ireland made 'fundamental mistake' in joining single currency


EU funds helping to 'prop up' corrupt regimes


Shamed MEP tells of 'bitterness' over 'cash-for-laws' scandal


Ukraine PM attempts to defuse tension over Tymoshenko case


EU accused of driving bluefin tuna to 'brink of extinction'


Article Comments

Could you please advise what, if anything, is to happen to the person or persons responsible for initiating the alteration of the software in the first place and, if they are still employed, could you tell me why?

Mr R Williams
7th Mar 2011 at 12:48 pm

More from Dods