Suspects to get EU 'letter of rights'

Suspects to get EU 'letter of rights'

Controversial and delayed EU rules to safeguard the rights of crime suspects will be unveiled by the European Commission next week.

Rows over a legal basis and pressure from some national capitals have dogged proposals initially planned for last November.

Included in the Brussels initiative will be calls for a 'letter of rights' to be given to all crime suspects on arrival at a police station.

Wednesday's safeguards will herald further controversial commission blueprints on bail and the detention of suspects in May.

EU justice chief Antonio Vitorino last September trailed proposals "which will, I put this very diplomatically, generate lively debate".

As the Portuguese commissioner predicted, early drafts generated "anxiety" among national governments concerned at the commission's interpretation of EU treaty law.

The new proposals will, say EU officials, "steer a middle course" and "very delicate" steps have had to be taken by justice draftsmen tip-toeing around national anti-terror legislation.

Various capitals have enacted legislation which departs from the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

Under national security exceptions to the ECHR, UK anti-terror laws - for example - allow foreign suspects to be held indefinitely without trial.

A Brussels consultation on the procedural safeguards noted that "numerous international and European instruments exist conferring rights on suspects".

"Yet, in many cases, it would seem that these rights are ignored or flouted. In some cases, the suspect is unaware of those rights."

Vitorino is suggesting "a simple, inexpensive remedy": a  'letter of rights' for all arrested suspects.

Early versions of the documents include a wide range of rights and the April 28 version may drop or qualify certain pledges.

Rules giving a 'right to silence', to guard against self incrimination vary across Europe.

And international conventions ensuring that foreign suspects have the right to consular assistance have not been signed by Portugal, Spain, Greece and the Netherlands.

The Parliament Magazine

Issue 291 | 22 June 2009The heart of Europe

Vladimír Špidla on Employment Week, the commission's social recovery plan and what the EU can do to protect jobs

Regional Review

Issue 13 | June 2009Be prepared

Margot Wallström on the financial crisis, Lisbon treaty and what Sweden must do to ensure a successful EU presidency

Research Review

Issue 9 | May 2009It's all in the mind

Get the lowdown and all the latest news from two key research conferences featuring the best of EU-funded projects

Advertise

Spread your message to an audience that counts, with options available for The Parliament Magazine, Regional Review and Research Review.