Fears over EU expansion branded 'unfounded'

Bookmark and Share

By Martin Banks
- 17th January 2008

Fears that the EU would be swamped with migrants from eastern Europe following its latest expansion have been dispelled as a “myth”.

A new report by the European Citizen Action Service (ECAS) focuses on the impact of Bulgaria and Romania’s entry to the EU in January 2007.

It says that most emigration from the two former communist countries took place “well before” accession and involved traditional countries of destination, including Greece, Spain and Portugal.

Some EU countries imposed measures restricting access to their labour markets for job-hunters from Bulgaria and Romania.

But, in the report, ECAS says labour migration has contributed to growth rates and, generally, complemented the domestic workforce in most countries.

“This report ought finally to put to rest the myth of the Polish plumber,” said Tony Venables, director of the Brussels-based organisation.

“Restrictions based on exaggerated predictions of an influx of job seekers or a deviation of mobility to countries opening up their labour markets proved unfounded.

“Transitional measures were taken after the horse bolted.”

ECAS says that only 10, mostly new member states, opened up their markets to Bulgaria and Romania.

“Amongst the countries that chose to restrict access to their labour markets, the most notable U-turn is that of the UK and Ireland, both switching from a liberal approach,” said Venables.

The report suggests they should “think twice” and the other 13 member states should change their minds.

The report, published during this week’s parliamentary plenary in Strasbourg, calls on the commission to end transitional measures.

It says, “While transitional arrangements from the 2004 enlargement are tending to be phased out, the new ones in the case of Bulgaria and Romania have little justification.”

ECAS was set up in 1991 to promote the rights of EU citizens.

Bookmark and Share

Have your say...

Please enter your comments below.

Name

Your e-mail address


Listen to audio version

Please type in the letters or numbers shown above (case sensitive)

Related News

Croatia's EU accession called into question

EU welcomes association agreement with Ukraine

MEPs call on Croatia to combat homophobia as part of EU bid

UK deputy says 2012 is 'crucial' for Macedonia's EU ambitions

EU expansion has sparked 'profound transformation' in accession countries



Latest news

MEPs brand EU fisheries policy as 'catastrophic'

MEPs have described a new report by European auditors on the EU's management of fish stocks as "damning"


Hungary's media laws branded 'deeply troubling'

EU commissioner Neelie Kroes has launched a withering verbal attack on Hungary's media laws, branding them as "deeply troubling"


EU 'must protect consumers' from excessive roaming charges

The EU has been urged to do more to ensure fair pricing for mobile phone users when travelling abroad


Leading commission official allays fears of '1930s-style slump'


McMillan-Scott lambasts China for its 'abhorrent' record


Veteran UK deputy appointed rapporteur on controversial ACTA dossier


Homeless people 'excluded' from European rights


EU urged to 'keep up the pressure' on Iran


More from Dods